Inconsistent Feedback
Privacy Violation : Inconsistent Feedback
OWASP Top 10:
PCI 3.2:
Summary
When entering an invalid user name or password during a login, forgotten password, profile updates or new user signup function, the application provides meaningful feedback through a response discrepancy. For the potential attacker, this discrepancy increases the chances of a successful brute force attack against the site's authentication.
Explanation
A successful brute force attack against the site's authentication would place the application user's personal information at risk as well as increase the likelihood of fraud within the application.
Execution
Due to the application providing meaningful feedback, an attacker can utilize a large list of potential usernames and/or email addresses to determine valid accounts.
Recommendation
The application should not indicate specifically whether a user account or password was incorrect, rather a very generic message stating that the login failed should be used. During a new user registration, profile updates or forgotten password function, no meaningful message should be returned to the requestor or noticeable application reaction, rather an email should be sent to the account in question with details of how to reset a forgotten password or reclaim an account.

Comments
Post a Comment